What Is the Winter Garden Housing Market Doing in October 2026?

Winter Garden Village at Fowler Groves, an open-air shopping center in Winter Garden.
Image: Jared Jones Team
Quick answer
As of September 2026, ZIP 34787 recorded 173 detached-home and townhome closings at a median $683,000 and $254.76 per sq ft, with a median 43 days on market (Stellar MLS, pulled Oct 2, 2026). Price per square foot has held near $252–$255 since July.
| Fact | Figure |
|---|---|
| Closed sales, Sep 2026 (detached + townhome) | 173 (152 detached / 21 townhome) |
| Median sold price, Sep 2026 | $683,000 |
| Median price per sq ft, Sep 2026 | $254.76 (Aug $254.37; Jul $252.15) |
| Median days on market (CDOM), Sep 2026 | 43 (Aug 28; Jul 23) |
| Resale median days on market, Sep 2026 | 50.5 (Aug 36.5; Jul 24.5) |
| Median sale-to-list, Sep 2026 | 98% |
| Active listings, Oct 2, 2026 | 565 (median list $684,990) |
| Months of supply (our calculation) | About 3.5 (565 ÷ 162.7 average monthly closings) |
| 12-month median, Oct 2, 2025–Sep 30, 2026 | $609,282 (1,952 closings) |
| Orange County median (rolling 3 mo), Sep 2026 | $440,000 (+0.6% year over year) |
Sources: Stellar MLS, Sep 2026; Stellar MLS, Oct 2 export; Stellar MLS via InfoSparks.
Jared walks through Winter Garden inventory and whether it is a good time to buy. Use the current figures on this page rather than any numbers mentioned in the video.
This update covers detached homes and townhomes in ZIP 34787, which includes the 34787 portion of Horizon West. Resale means built in 2024 or earlier; new construction means built in 2025 or 2026.
What did Winter Garden homes sell for in September 2026?
ZIP 34787 closed 173 homes in September 2026 at a median $683,000, up from $605,000 in August. That jump is mostly about the mix of homes that closed, not a sudden price change. A larger share of September closings were detached homes (152 of 173, compared with 138 of 170 in August), and the 57 new-construction closings sold at a median $705,000 against $627,500 for resale homes. Price per square foot barely moved, from $254.37 in August to $254.76 in September.
| Month | Closed | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| July 2026 | 169 | $664,000 | $252.15 | 23 |
| August 2026 | 170 | $605,000 | $254.37 | 28 |
| September 2026 | 173 | $683,000 | $254.76 | 43 |
By quarter, Q3 2026 (July–September) closed 512 homes at a median $638,698 and $254.07 per square foot, compared with 530 homes at $596,500 and $258.67 per square foot in Q2 2026. In September, detached homes closed at a median $718,995 and townhomes at a median $400,000.
How fast are Winter Garden homes selling right now?
Resale homes are the clearest signal. Their median cumulative days on market was 50.5 days in September 2026, up from 36.5 in August and 24.5 in July. Across all closings, including new construction, the September median was 43 days, up from 28 in August. Over the 12 months to Sep 30, 2026, the median was 33 days overall and 40 days for resale homes. The median sale-to-list ratio held at 98%.
Builder closings are often entered in the MLS at or near closing, so their days on market can read close to zero and pull the combined median down. For detail by price band, see how long it takes to sell a home in Winter Garden.
How much inventory is on the market?
The Stellar MLS showed 565 active detached homes and townhomes in ZIP 34787 on Oct 2, 2026 (454 detached and 111 townhomes), at a median list price of $684,990 and $270.01 per square foot. Active listings had been on the market a median 71 days so far.
That works out to about 3.5 months of supply at the 12-month sales pace, or 3.3 months at the Q3 pace. For comparison, InfoSparks data shows 4.9 months of supply for Orange County as a whole in September 2026.
How does September compare with last year?
A September 2025 comparison for this exact area is not in our current MLS dataset. For year-over-year context, Stellar MLS data via InfoSparks for all of Orange County shows September 2026 closed sales of 1,097 versus 1,339 a year earlier (down 18.1%), a rolling three-month median of $440,000 versus $437,500 (up 0.6%), 6,406 homes for sale versus 6,340 (up 1.0%), and rolling three-month pending sales of 3,838 versus 4,052 (down 5.3%). Months of supply was 4.9 in both years. Call or text 407-706-5000 and we will pull the year-over-year numbers for your neighborhood.
What does this mean if you are selling?
Price to current price-per-square-foot comps for homes like yours, and expect negotiation to land near 98% of list, the September median. Resale homes took a median 50.5 days on market in September, so build that time into your moving plan. Budget your seller closing costs in Winter Garden early so you know your net.
What does this mean if you are buying?
New construction closed at a median $705,000 in September and resale at $627,500, so compare total cost, not just price. Our new construction vs resale guide, affordability guide and buyer closing costs guide walk through the math. Builder communities with recent 34787 closings include Serenade at Ovation, Northlake at Ovation and Osprey Ranch. For tax estimates, see Winter Garden property taxes.
When will October numbers be posted?
October 2026 numbers will be added after the Stellar MLS month-end pull in early November. This page is updated in place each month, and the Updated date at the top shows the latest refresh.
Want to know what your Winter Garden home would sell for this month, or what a specific listing should cost? Call or text 407-706-5000.
Frequently asked questions
What is the median home price in Winter Garden right now?
In September 2026, ZIP 34787 detached homes and townhomes sold for a median $683,000 across 173 closings (Stellar MLS). The 12-month median through Sep 30, 2026 was $609,282. September ran higher partly because a larger share of detached homes closed that month, while price per square foot stayed near $255.
Is Winter Garden a buyer’s or seller’s market in October 2026?
The data sits in the middle. ZIP 34787 had about 3.5 months of supply on Oct 2, 2026, compared with 4.9 months for Orange County in September, and homes sold at a median 98% of list price. Your price range and home type matter more than any single label.
How long does it take to sell a home in Winter Garden?
Homes in ZIP 34787 that closed in September 2026 spent a median 43 days on market, and resale homes a median 50.5 days. Over the 12 months to Sep 30, 2026, the median was 33 days overall and 40 for resale. Our how-long-to-sell guide breaks this down by price band.
Do new-construction homes sell for more than resale in Winter Garden?
In September 2026, 57 new-construction homes in ZIP 34787 closed at a median $705,000, while 116 resale homes closed at a median $627,500 (Stellar MLS). Home size and type affect both medians, so compare price per square foot and total cost, not just the median price.
Does this Winter Garden report include Horizon West?
Yes, it includes the part of Horizon West with a 34787 mailing address, because the report covers the whole ZIP code. Horizon West homes with 34786 addresses are not included. Our separate Horizon West market update covers the villages and Town Center on their own.
How often is this market update refreshed?
We refresh this page monthly after the Stellar MLS month-end update, usually in the first week of the following month. The Updated date at the top of the page shows the latest refresh. Call or text 407-706-5000 anytime for current numbers on a specific home or neighborhood.
Sources
- Stellar MLS, Jared Jones Team search: ZIP 34787 detached and townhome closings Oct 2, 2025–Sep 30, 2026 plus active listings, pulled Oct 2, 2026
- Stellar MLS via InfoSparks (ShowingTime), Orange County, data as of Oct 1, 2026
- Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty, Oct 2026
Related Wave 1 guides
- Winter Garden & Horizon West Real Estate (2026) hub
- Horizon West Housing Market Update: October 2026
- How Long Does It Take to Sell a Home in Winter Garden? (2026)
- Seller Closing Costs in Winter Garden (2026)
- New Construction vs Resale in Horizon West 2026
- How Much House Can I Afford in Horizon West? (2026)
- Buyer Closing Costs Winter Garden 2026
- Winter Garden Property Taxes 2026
- Plant Street vs Horizon West
- Winter Garden Real Estate
Related: Orlando Real Estate Outlook 2026
Watch: Orlando housing market update (October 2026 video)
Buying or selling in Winter Garden or Horizon West?
Get street-level pricing, an honest commute read and a clear plan to close. Call or text 407-706-5000.
Jared Jones
Jared Jones leads the Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty, helping buyers and sellers in Winter Garden, Horizon West and greater Orlando. He has about 24 years of real estate experience and approximately 4,000 transactions.
Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty · 504 W Plant Street, 1st and 2nd Floors, Winter Garden, FL 34787 · 407-706-5000 · jaredjones.com