Jared Jones Full Width Modern Header
Johns Lake · Winter Garden

Hickory Hammock Homes for Sale in Winter Garden, FL

A gated community of single-family homes and townhomes on Johns Lake, just west of SR 429, with a community dock, resort-style pool and tennis courts, and homes mostly built 2015–2017.

Written by Jared Jones Updated October 2026 Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty
$907,500Median sold price (12 months · 28 sales)
27 daysMedian days on market
2015–2017Typical year built (middle 50% of sales)

Stellar MLS sold data, closings Oct 5, 2025 through Oct 2, 2026.

At a glance (as of October 2026)
FactFigure
Median sold price (last 12 months)$907,500 (28 sales)
Median price per sq ft$296
Median days on market27 days
Single-family median (sold)$1,109,180 (22 sales)
Townhome median (sold)$390,000 (5 sales)
Typical year-built range2015–2017 (middle 50% of sales)
HOAMandatory HOA, gated community. Ask us for the current dues on any home you like.
LakeJohns Lake on the north side; community dock and fishing
ZIP / area34787 · Winter Garden, west of SR 429

Sources: Stellar MLS (sold closings 2025-10-05–2026-10-02); Jared Jones Team community notes (gate, HOA, amenities, builders and neighboring areas, Oct 2026).

Where is Hickory Hammock in Winter Garden?

Hickory Hammock is a gated neighborhood off Avalon Road and Marsh Road, just west of SR 429, in the Winter Garden 34787 ZIP. Johns Lake and wetlands border it to the north, Stoneybrook West sits to the east and Twinwaters to the west. SR 429 gives quick access to Walt Disney World, I-4 and Florida’s Turnpike, and Winter Garden Village shopping is minutes away.

Location snapshot

  • ZIP: 34787
  • Access: off Avalon Road and Marsh Road
  • North: Johns Lake
  • East: Stoneybrook West
  • West: Twinwaters

What’s around

  • Retail / dining: Stoneybrook West Village
  • Mall: Winter Garden Village
  • Hospital: AdventHealth Winter Garden
  • Trail: West Orange Trail
  • Schools: check Orange County Find My School by address

What amenities does Hickory Hammock include?

Hickory Hammock is gated and has a mandatory HOA. Amenities include a community dock and fishing on Johns Lake, a resort-style pool, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis courts, a park and playground, sidewalks, reclaimed-water irrigation and golf cart-friendly streets. Of the 28 homes sold in the last 12 months, 12 listed a private pool. Always confirm which amenities are active and what the current HOA dues cover before you write an offer, and check the tax bill on each address for any CDD line.

GatedGated entry into the neighborhood
Lake accessCommunity dock and fishing on Johns Lake
Pool & clubhouseResort-style pool and clubhouse
Fitness & courtsFitness center and tennis courts
Parks & playPark, playground, sidewalks, golf carts allowed
FeesMandatory HOA; confirm CDD on the tax bill for each parcel

What do Hickory Hammock homes typically look like?

Hickory Hammock was built mostly between 2014 and 2018 by several builders, including CalAtlantic, Ryland, M/I Homes and Lennar, in Florida, Craftsman, Traditional and Contemporary styles. Single-family homes sold in the last 12 months ran about 1,860–5,602 square feet with 3–5 bedrooms, and townhomes ran about 1,844–2,444 square feet with 3 bedrooms. Twelve sales closed at $1 million or more, mostly larger homes on streets near the water such as Johns Lake Overlook Drive and Lake Claire Overlook Drive. Lots range from zero-lot-line to about a quarter acre, and some homes back to park, wooded or Johns Lake and Lake Claire views. Treat every range as typical, not a guarantee for a specific listing.

How does Hickory Hammock compare to nearby Winter Garden options?

Buyers often weigh Hickory Hammock against Independence and Lakeview Preserve for other established Winter Garden neighborhoods, and against Horizon West communities like Summerlake and Waterleigh when they want a resort-style HOA farther south. Fees vary widely across these areas, so read HOA Fees in Winter Garden & Horizon West (2026) before you compare, browse Independence homes for sale for a nearby alternative, then use this page for active inventory.

Winter Garden & Horizon West area overview: city-wide context, not Hickory Hammock-specific. Watch when you want the bigger picture.

Frequently asked questions

Is Hickory Hammock a gated community?

Yes. Hickory Hammock is a gated community of single-family homes and townhomes off Avalon Road and Marsh Road, just west of SR 429, with a mandatory HOA that covers a pool, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis courts and a community dock.

Does Hickory Hammock have lake access?

Yes. Johns Lake borders the community to the north, and the HOA amenities include a community dock and fishing. Some homes also back to Johns Lake or Lake Claire water views.

What have homes in Hickory Hammock sold for?

Across 28 closings from October 5, 2025 through October 2, 2026, the median sold price was $907,500, or $296 per square foot, with a median of 27 days on market. Single-family homes had a median of $1,109,180 across 22 sales and townhomes a median of $390,000 across 5 sales.

Who built Hickory Hammock?

Several builders delivered homes here, mostly between 2014 and 2018, including CalAtlantic, Ryland, M/I Homes and Lennar. Style and finish level vary by builder and phase, so compare recent sold comps in the same section of the neighborhood.

How do I see current Hickory Hammock homes for sale?

Use the live listings block on this page for active inventory, or call or text the Jared Jones Team at 407-706-5000. We can also set a custom alert for new Hickory Hammock and nearby Winter Garden listings that match your budget and must-haves.

Browse nearby

Thinking about a home in Hickory Hammock?

Call or text the Jared Jones Team at 407-706-5000. We will pull current comps, confirm HOA and CDD on the addresses you like, and set up showings.

About the author

Jared Jones

Jared Jones leads the Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty, serving Winter Garden, Horizon West, and Greater Orlando. Office: 504 W Plant Street, 1st and 2nd Floors, Winter Garden, FL 34787. Phone: 407-706-5000.

Shopping Basket