Jared Jones Full Width Modern Header
Winter Garden

What Lakes Can You Live On in Winter Garden and Horizon West? (2026)

Written by Jared Jones
Updated November 2026
Winter Garden & Horizon West Real Estate Hub
Aerial view of Hickorynut Lake at sunset near Avalon Road in Horizon West, Florida, with a small wooded island
Sunset over Hickorynut Lake near Avalon Road in Horizon West. Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake are three separate lakes, not one connected chain.

Photo: jaredjones.com

As of November 2026, three Winter Garden area lakes let you live on the water: Johns Lake at 2,580 acres, Lake Hancock at 476 acres and Hickorynut Lake at 403 acres, per the Orange County Water Atlas. They are three separate lakes, not one connected chain.

2,580 acresJohns Lake surface water
476 acresLake Hancock surface water
403 acresHickorynut Lake surface water
3Separate lakes, not one chain
At a glance (as of November 2026)
Fact Figure
Johns Lake surface area 2,580 acres
Johns Lake mean depth 12 ft
Lake Hancock surface area 476 acres
Hickorynut Lake surface area 403 acres
Johns Lake Conservation Area 138 acres
Johns Lake county line Lake and Orange counties
One connected chain No, three separate lakes

Sources: Orange County Water Atlas (USF Water Institute) for Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake surface areas and depth; St. Johns River Water Management District for Johns Lake; Orange County news release for the Johns Lake Conservation Area (all checked November 16, 2026).

In this July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones walks through what is new and coming soon to Winter Garden. Around the ten minute mark he talks through the area’s lakes, including Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and the one he calls Lake Hickory Nut. This page covers the facts behind that lakes chapter: which lakes you can live on, how big they are and where the public can reach the water.

Which lakes can you live on in Winter Garden and Horizon West?

Three main lakes near Winter Garden and Horizon West let you buy a home on the water: Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake, which Jared Jones calls Lake Hickory Nut. The Orange County Water Atlas, produced with the USF Water Institute, lists Johns Lake at 2,580 acres, Lake Hancock at 476 acres and Hickorynut Lake at 403 acres.

These are not the same as the Butler Chain of Lakes in Windermere. Johns Lake sits in the Lake Apopka watershed, Hickorynut Lake in the Reedy Creek watershed, and Lake Hancock in both, per the Water Atlas. Hickorynut Lake also appears on the Atlas under the alternate name Little Hickorynut.

How big are Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake?

Johns Lake is the largest. The Orange County Water Atlas lists it at 2,580 acres with a mean depth of 12 feet. The St. Johns River Water Management District describes Johns Lake as about 2,500 acres and a regionally important recreational resource with county parks and access for canoeing, kayaking and other watersports, and says it sits on the border of Lake and Orange counties.

Lake Hancock covers 476 acres in unincorporated Orange County, in the Lake Apopka and Reedy Creek watersheds. Hickorynut Lake covers 403 acres in unincorporated Orange County, in the Reedy Creek watershed. In his July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones rounded Johns Lake to about 2,300 acres, so figures vary by source and survey date.

Are Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake a connected chain?

No. Unlike the Butler Chain of Lakes, which links 13 lakes through navigable canals, Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake are separate waterbodies in different parts of west Orange County and the Winter Garden area. There is no single chain connecting them, so each lake has its own shoreline, access and rules.

Because of that, the experience differs from lake to lake. Confirm which lake a home actually fronts, since a nearby pond or canal is not the same as frontage on Johns Lake, Lake Hancock or Hickorynut Lake.

Where can the public get on the water?

Johns Lake has the clearest public access. The Johns Lake Conservation Area, at 880 Avalon Road in Winter Garden, covers 138 acres and, per an Orange County release, includes a trailhead to the lake shore, a fishing pier, a kayak and canoe launch, picnic areas and a bird blind. The county says it is open sunrise to sunset, so confirm current hours and any closures before you go.

Lake County also lists a public boat ramp on Johns Lake. Our research could not verify the exact street address on the county page, so check the address, parking and hours on the Lake County boat ramps page first. For Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake, public trailer ramp access was not confirmed on official county parks pages as of November 16, 2026, and many homes there use private or community docks.

What does Jared Jones say about these lakes?

In his July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones ranks Johns Lake as his favorite lake setting in Winter Garden, followed by Lake Hancock and then Lake Hickory Nut, his name for Hickorynut Lake. That is his personal ranking, not an official rating. He says that if you want a boatable, skiable lake in the area, those three are the ones to consider.

He also notes that the west side of Johns Lake sits in Lake County and the east side in Orange County, so a home can carry a Winter Garden address with Lake County property taxes. He gives a tax estimate in the video, but we did not verify millage side by side, so check the tax bill and the county for any specific property before you buy.

On communities, Jared Jones points to Deer Island, a gated area off Highway 50 on Johns Lake with older homes and water views, and Turkey Island as a small island setting in the middle of the lake. He associates Hamlin Town Center with Lake Hancock and the Waterleigh neighborhood with Lake Hickory Nut.

What should buyers check on a lakefront home here?

Check the water frontage, the access and the taxes. Confirm whether the lot fronts the open lake, a cove or a canal, and whether any dock was permitted. Because Johns Lake straddles two counties, verify which county a property is in and review the actual tax bill rather than relying on a general estimate.

Also confirm boat and ramp access for the specific lake, since public trailer ramps are not listed for every lake here. Anyone who plans to fish should check current Florida fish consumption advisories for the lake. For nearby growth, the Johns Lake Urban Village approval and local community guides show what is planned around these lakes.

Have questions about buying or selling here? Call or text 407-706-5000 or visit jaredjones.com.

Jared Jones Team, Brokered by eXp Realty.

Frequently asked questions

What lakes can you live on in Winter Garden and Horizon West?

Three main lakes let you buy a home on the water near Winter Garden and Horizon West: Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake. The Orange County Water Atlas lists Johns Lake at 2,580 acres, Lake Hancock at 476 acres and Hickorynut Lake at 403 acres. They are three separate lakes, not one connected chain, so confirm the exact lake before you buy.

How big is Johns Lake?

The Orange County Water Atlas lists Johns Lake at 2,580 acres with a mean depth of 12 feet, in the Lake Apopka watershed. The St. Johns River Water Management District describes it as about 2,500 acres and a regionally important recreational resource. In his July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones rounded it to about 2,300 acres, so numbers vary by source and date.

Are Johns Lake, Lake Hancock and Hickorynut Lake a connected chain?

No. Unlike the Butler Chain of Lakes in Windermere, these three waterbodies are separate and sit in different parts of the Winter Garden area and west Orange County. The Water Atlas places Johns Lake in the Lake Apopka watershed, Hickorynut Lake in the Reedy Creek watershed, and Lake Hancock in both. Each lake has its own access, so check how you reach the water before you buy.

Is there public access to Johns Lake?

Yes. The Johns Lake Conservation Area at 880 Avalon Road in Winter Garden covers 138 acres and, per an Orange County release, has a trailhead to the lake shore, a fishing pier, a kayak and canoe launch, picnic areas and a bird blind. Lake County also lists a public boat ramp on Johns Lake. Confirm current hours, parking and the address with the county before you go.

Can you boat and ski on these lakes?

In his July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones says that if you want a boatable, skiable lake in the Winter Garden area, you should look at Johns Lake, Lake Hancock or Hickorynut Lake, which he calls Lake Hickory Nut. That is his opinion, not an official rating. Public trailer ramp access was not confirmed on county parks pages for Lake Hancock or Hickorynut Lake, so confirm access first.

What is Deer Island on Johns Lake?

In his July 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones describes Deer Island as a gated community you enter from Highway 50 on Johns Lake, with older homes he estimates at about 20 to 25 years old and water views. He also mentions Turkey Island as a small island setting in the middle of the lake. Confirm the exact community, whether a lot is on the water and any HOA rules before you buy.

Shopping Basket