Jared Jones Full Width Modern Header
Winter Garden Acreage

What Is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement in Winter Garden? Acreage Homes Between Winter Garden and Horizon West

Written by Jared Jones
Updated October 2026
Winter Garden & Horizon West Hub

As of October 2026, the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement is a 2,236-acre rural area in unincorporated Orange County between Winter Garden and Horizon West. One home per five acres is the main density. Jared Jones says raw 5-acre parcels there run about $750,000 to $1 million.

At a glance (as of October 2026)
Fact Figure
Size 2,236 acres, stretching about 3.5 miles
Location Unincorporated Orange County; Winter Garden to the north, Horizon West to the south
Designated a rural settlement May 2004
Main density 1 home per 5 acres
Lake Avalon Groves plat recorded Sept. 18, 1924
Rural Preservation District ordinance Approved June 4, 2024
Raw 5-acre land, as cited by Jared Jones About $750,000 to $1 million, sometimes more

Sources: Orange County Government, Avalon Rural Settlement page (checked Oct 27, 2026); West Orange Times & Observer, July 4, 2024; Jared Jones – Orlando Living (YouTube), video published Oct 2, 2026.

Jared Jones walks through six parts of the Orlando area for buyers spending $1 million to $1.5 million, from Lake Nona to Winter Park. In the Winter Garden stop, he calls the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement a hidden gem: multi-acre land a few minutes from Hamlin Town Center. This page covers only that settlement.

What is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement?

It is a protected rural community in unincorporated Orange County, set between the city of Winter Garden and Horizon West. The Orange County Board of County Commissioners designated it a rural settlement in May 2004.

Orange County says the community’s history dates back to the 1920s, and the West Orange Times & Observer reports the Lake Avalon Groves plat was recorded on Sept. 18, 1924. The settlement covers 2,236 acres and stretches about 3.5 miles, per the Observer. Limited neighborhood, commercial and office uses are allowed to support residents, according to the county. Residents told the Observer it is one of only 21 rural settlements in Orange County. In the video, Jared describes it as a place where you can feel like you live in the middle of nowhere while being on the edge of everything.

How big are the lots in Lake Avalon?

Large by Winter Garden standards. The Observer reports one home per five acres is the predominant land use designation, and Jared describes homes on 2.5 to 5 acres.

Some parcels carry other rural settlement designations, such as one home per two acres. Changing a parcel to allow more homes is not routine: in June 2024 the County Commission denied a request to change one Avalon Rural Settlement property from one home per five acres to one home per two acres so the lot could be split, after neighbors spoke against it, per the Observer. Before you buy, check the parcel’s future land use and zoning with Orange County rather than assuming a lot can be divided.

What does land cost in the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement?

Jared says the land alone for 5 acres in the area runs from about $750,000 to almost $1 million, and in some cases over $1 million for raw land.

That is why he says a $1.2 million to $1.3 million budget here buys mostly land, and the house itself may be modest compared with what the same money buys in a newer Horizon West neighborhood. He also notes that some owners who would sell will not put their homes on the market, so off-market conversations matter in this pocket. These are Jared’s working estimates from the video, not an appraisal. Ask for recent closed sales on comparable acreage before you make an offer. Call or text 407-706-5000 and the Jared Jones Team can pull them.

What does the Rural Preservation District do?

It makes it harder for a city to annex land in the settlement. Orange County approved an ordinance recognizing the Lake Avalon Rural Preservation District on June 4, 2024, per the Observer.

Before the ordinance, annexation needed a majority vote of the County Commission. Under the district, a second step applies: a majority of settlement residents must also vote in favor before a city can annex a parcel, according to Laurie Forrester, president of the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement and Avalon Home and Property Owners Association, as quoted by the Observer. The goal, per the Observer, is to preserve the community’s rural character. Jared says in the video that residents push back hard when developers try to nibble at the edges.

Who is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement a good fit for?

Buyers who want land and privacy but still want to be close to Horizon West shopping and SR 429. Jared puts it about 5 to 10 minutes from Hamlin Town Center and 20 to 25 minutes from Disney.

The trade-offs are the flip side of the appeal. Growth surrounds the settlement, so roads and new neighborhoods nearby will keep changing. Older homes on acreage can need more upkeep than new construction, and wells, septic systems and outbuildings deserve a close inspection. Buyers who want a new, low-maintenance home in a planned neighborhood will likely be happier elsewhere in Winter Garden. For nearby options, see the Lake Avalon Groves and Horizon West guides linked below.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement?

The Lake Avalon Rural Settlement is a 2,236-acre rural community in unincorporated Orange County, between Winter Garden to the north and Horizon West to the south. Orange County designated it a rural settlement in May 2004, and its history dates back to the 1920s. One home per five acres is the predominant density.

Where is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement?

It sits in unincorporated west Orange County between the city of Winter Garden and Horizon West, stretching about 3.5 miles, per the West Orange Times & Observer. In his Oct 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones places it near SR 429, about 5 to 10 minutes from Hamlin Town Center and about 20 to 25 minutes from Disney.

How much does 5 acres cost in Lake Avalon?

In his Oct 2, 2026 video, Jared Jones says raw land for 5 acres in the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement runs from about $750,000 to almost $1 million, and sometimes over $1 million. At a $1.2 million to $1.3 million budget, most of the value is in the land. Ask for recent comparable sales before you offer.

Can you split a lot in the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement?

It is difficult. One home per five acres is the predominant designation, and in June 2024 the Orange County Commission denied a request to change one property to one home per two acres so it could be split, per the West Orange Times & Observer. Check a parcel’s land use and zoning with Orange County first.

What is the Lake Avalon Rural Preservation District?

It is a district Orange County approved by ordinance on June 4, 2024, to preserve the settlement’s rural character. It adds a step to annexation: besides a County Commission majority vote, a majority of settlement residents must also vote in favor before a city can annex a parcel, per the West Orange Times & Observer.

Is the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement part of Winter Garden?

No. It is unincorporated Orange County land, even though it sits between the city of Winter Garden and Horizon West and many people describe it as Winter Garden. The 2024 Rural Preservation District made annexation by a city harder by requiring a vote of settlement residents, per the West Orange Times & Observer.

Shopping Basket